The best review from an iPad skeptic I’ve seen. Maybe skeptic isn’t the right word, but clearly he’s unconvinced that it’s the next big thing.
This is a minor point in his piece:
And pragmatically, experience has shown that the winning computer
platforms are the ones you can develop for on the computer itself,
and the ones that require other, more expensive hardware and
software, don’t become platforms. There are exceptions but it’s
remarkable how often it works this way.
I think that’s only true historically. I don’t think it’s true any more, especially in the mobile space. And it was never true for consoles, and the iPad in some ways is like a cross between a mobile device and a console. But, all that said, I’d love to be able to develop for the iPad on the iPad. Especially if it were a HyperCard-like thing, where the output looked native to the iPad but was based on WebKit behind the scenes, thus allowing the apps made by the thing to be openly distributed and shared with other iPad users.
★ Tuesday, 6 April 2010