A rule banning “Rate This App” dialogs would have the same
problem: since the dialog is unlikely to appear during app review
(and could be easily coded to guarantee that it wouldn’t),
they’ll almost never reject anything for it. Once an app is in the
wild, there’s no good way for Apple to be reliably notified of
violations, and even if they added one, the line between
permissible and prohibited would be vague and easy to skirt.
We could all rate these apps lower as a form of protest, but
it’s unlikely to have a meaningful impact. The App Store is a
I agree that Apple, practically speaking, couldn’t ban this practice. But I’m not so sure that a groundswell campaign to rate these apps poorly wouldn’t work. The App Store is indeed a big place, but there aren’t that many reviews for most apps, even popular ones.