Stephen Hackett, “The Case Against Control Center”:
I don’t think this has aged very well, unfortunately, and it’s
mostly Control Center’s fault. In addition to it being confusing
to have a hidden panel at the top of the screen, having one at the
bottom too is a lot to handle for some users. But there’s a bigger
problem in my mind: Control Center just does way too many things.
I love the top row and screen brightness settings, but as I get
closer to the bottom of the screen, the usefulness of Control
Center lessens. With the exception of maybe the flashlight button,
I’d be fine if the bottom row went away, Calculator and that
creepy new Night Mode button included.
I think Apple could simplify all of this by looking to Android’s
Notifications Drawer, where all of this stuff is in one
pull-down tray from the top of the screen. Pull down a little to
see notifications; pull down further to reveal a set of utilities.
I couldn’t disagree more strenuously. Control Center is probably my single favorite system-level UI change to iOS ever. I kind of wish you could change the apps hard-coded at the bottom (I’d replace Calculator with PCalc, for example), but I use it all the time.
I think Notification Center and Today view could still use some improvement. But cramming Control Center into the same pull-down sheet would make things worse, not better. Putting the dynamic Notification Center at the top and the static Control Center at the bottom provides a consistent spatial familiarity. It makes these features feel like they’re part of the hardware. (And I think Android might have to make them both pull-down-from-the-top because Android phones have soft buttons at the bottom of the display.)
★ Saturday, 30 January 2016